You are here: Home

all things new

ecce nova facio omnia

Lessons from Humanae Vitae

E-mail Print PDF
Lessons from Humanae Vitae

Almost half a century ago Pope Paul VI presented his encyclical Humanae Vitae to the Church and the world. In modern times few popes have been as maligned as Paul VI. He carried a heavy cross in his time but now, half a century after his most famous and controversial encyclical, history is vindicating him. Reading about Humanae Vitae and the history of the contraception pill reminded me of a passage in the Apocalypse of St. John:

“And a mighty angel took up a stone, as it were a great millstone, and cast it into the sea, saying: With such violence as this shall Babylon, that great city, be thrown down, and shall be found no more at all.” Revelation 18:21

I think this passage can be used to illustrate what happened to our world since 1960. Back then not a huge millstone was hurled into the “sea” of mankind but a tiny little pill, the first nearly 100% effective oral contraceptive. The ripple effects of the Pill were almost immediately felt, in particular in the United States and the rest of the developed countries of the western hemisphere. Our world has not been the same ever since.

In 1960 the mood of the Western world was optimistic in spite of the menace of a nuclear war between the USSR and the U.S. When I think of those years I think of John F. Kennedy, the Beatles, Miles Davis, the first astronauts, and the emergence of a new way of seeing morals and religion. All of it came together. There was a “cooler way” of doing things and the Pill was on its way to being accepted by many as a way to make life easier, less risky, and more enjoyable.

A contraceptive called Enovid 10 appeared in Britain at the crest of the post-war economic expansion and towards the end of the Baby Boom, a period roughly extending from 1946 to 1964 when some of the returning GI Joes and the former bobby soxers decided to marry and have big families. It was their way of forgetting about the recent war. The Baby Boom was waning when the Pill made its entrance.

In Britain, between 1962 and 1969, the number of women using the Pill rose from an estimated fifty thousand to about one million. In 1964, the Archbishop of Westminster pronounced himself against it, declaring that its use was “against the law of God.” Nevertheless the use of the Pill continued to rise worldwide.

Although it may prove impossible to connect the societal changes that followed the introduction of the Pill, one can hardly deny that easy contraception was a contributing factor to the social earthquake of the 1960’s. Morality changed, families became smaller, attitudes towards religion changed as Freudian psychoanalysis, Darwinian evolution, and Marxism became more and more mainstream.

The moral consequences of removing the possibility of pregnancy from sex outside of marriage and not just outside of marriage but within marriage as well — are quite evident after more than half a century. I will leave that aside since there are already many intelligent commentaries written on that topic. What I want to consider are angles of this problem that are not usually examined. To do that I need to return to the millstone of St. John’s Apocalypse but first we must recapitulate a time in history affected by some of the same elements we are considering. There is a parallel we need to notice.

In his book 1491, journalist and author Charles C. Mann argues that more than ninety percent of the aboriginal population in the Americas perished after contracting European diseases for which they had no natural defenses. Columbus and those who followed after him unwittingly transported those diseases into the New World. That decimation of native populations by European infirmities made the future immigration of Europeans much easier. Entire cultures were wiped out and replaced in spite of their self-sufficiency, sophistication and development.

If the 1491 argument is correct — as I think it is — then we can learn a valuable lesson from history that will help us understand some of the unintended social effects of the Pill. It is easy to see that if the Europeans had to confront large native populations, it would have been much harder for them to settle the New Continent so quickly and thoroughly. Think of India, or China, nations that were very hard to conque if not virtually impossible to dominate. European settlements there were limited to heavily protected ports, like Macao or Hong-Kong, where merchant vessels could anchor and trade with the inland populations.

If the Americas would have been as thickly settled as China, maybe New York and San Francisco could have been the American equivalents of Macao and Hong Kong. But it did not happen that way because of at least two sick men that we know about. One was a French sailor who survived a wreck near the coast of New England and was rescued by natives. Unfortunately for the natives that sailor was a carrier of viral hepatitis. He was primarily responsible for a plague that erased the coastal populations of Massachusetts. Years later when the Pilgrims arrived at Plymouth they found the empty Indian towns filled with dry food supplies and no inhabitants.

Something similar happened earlier farther south when Columbus’ crew introduced smallpox and other diseases after their arrival at Hispaniola Island. Today archeologists and historians can trace the destruction caused by the disease. By 1532 when Pizarro arrived in Peru the disease had spread to the continent, killing one out of four inhabitants of the Inca Empire. Among the dead were the emperor, Huaino Capac and his heir apparent. A civil war ensued between two surviving sons: Huascar and Atahualpa. The latter had just won the long and violent contest when Spaniards arrived and conquered the war-weary and disease-weakened empire.

The introduction of the contraceptive pill in our culture can be compared to the arrival of European viruses to the Americas in 1492. Just as the Native Americans were not prepared for such a vast calamity, our society was not prepared — not even aware — of the social, cultural, and economic consequences of the unbridled use of contraceptives. Ancient nations considered the “closing of the womb” one of the harshest divine punishments. What would ancient cultures think of us “closing the womb” of our own women by means of a self-administered nature-altering poison? Would they think we are committing societal suicide?

Consider these facts: no economy can grow without population growth. Then notice that the U.S. has been growing its economy on debt (just as many other developed countries have) since the early 1980’s. That would be about the time when the growing “hole” created by the Pill appeared in the American population. The pill impeded the birth of an undefined number of children between 1960 and 1965. If they had been born they should have entered the workforce and the consumer market in full force between 1980 and 1985 but they did not. In my opinion their absence explains the drag in the economy we have been experiencing since then.

I believe the “hole” in the population went undetected, gradually forcing governments to rely on debt and immigration to grow their economies. The extraordinary growth of the North American economy in the post-war period runs almost parallel with the Baby Boom. It is very likely that the lack of growth that has plagued the economies since the 1980’s could be related to the unnatural “Baby Bust” caused by the Pill. Our potential populations were decimated by an invisible killer that we can know only by its effects.

Even those ancient non-sophisticated civilizations knew that lots of babies meant lots of future farmers and soldiers, long periods of stable food supplies, and future happy elders taken care of by a populous younger generation. That was why they had fertility gods. One can go back to biblical times and the concept runs steady all the way to late modernity. Some say that the Pill means “choice” and “progress.” Well this is what “choice” and “progress” do to your culture: if Joey is not born, José or Yusuf will move in to take his place in the economy. Factories have to be manned; someone has to harvest the fields; armies have to recruit. So the “hole” in the expected population causes another undesired effect: massive immigration.

Another unintended effect of the Pill is a specific form of pollution. Since a woman’s body cannot break down the artificial progesterone designed to prevent her from having babies, her body eliminates the chemical with the urine. Then it returns via sewage to the water supply but nature cannot break it either and so it accumulates there. We are already seeing the genetic damage done to fish and small amphibians by those artificial chemical compounds now present in nearly every body of water on the planet.

Going back to the millstone of St. John’s Apocalypse ... The most destructive force the West has unleashed on the environment, the world's economy, and cultural stability is that tiny contraceptive pill. Think of it and if you can, please read the encyclical Humanae Vitae, even if you are not Catholic. I am sure you will find that the document was prophetic. Also carefully examine by yourself the statistics on the Pill's general availability and usage; compare the graphs to the economy, national debt, runaway immigration, violent crime, and abortion. You will see an eerie correlation.

Some say, “We are a nation of immigrants.” The trite phrase repeated like a mantra to justify uncontrolled immigration should rather be, “We are successful invaders that thrived far away from home.” The trick is not to let others do to us what our ancestors unwittingly did to the Cohasset and Seminoles, to the Taino and the Incas. Remember that the colonization of the Americas by Europeans would have been impossible if it were not for the European diseases that literally decimated the aboriginal nations since 1492, “making room” for European settlers.

Using the Pill and abortion to avoid having babies is basically killing our population even before they are born. There is no way around it. Opting to have fewer children may be our right but remember that practices have consequences. One consequence may be the extermination of your own kind or the assimilation of your few descendents into a different, more prolific group in three or four generations. Cultures are hard to erase but races can be gone easily in a century or two. We have seen that recently but few appear to be heeding the lessons of history.

If we want our nations and economies to survive we must stop fearing population growth. We must “think life” and thrive.



Must Read

Gun Control in the Third Reich: Disarming the Jews and Enemies of the State by Stephen P. Halbrook. Based on newly-discovered, secret documents from German archives, diaries and newspapers of the time, Gun Control in the Third Reich presents the definitive, yet hidden history of how the Nazi regime made use of gun control to disarm and repress its enemies and consolidate power. The countless books on the Third Reich and the Holocaust fail even to mention the laws restricting firearms ownership, which rendered political opponents and Jews defenseless.
No Crueler Tyrannies by Dorothy Rabinowitz. In this book, Pulitzer Prize-winning journalist Dorothy Rabinowitz re-frames the facts, reconsiders the evidence, and demystifies the proceedings of some of America's most harrowing cases of failed justice. Recalling the hysteria that accompanied the child sex-abuse witch-hunts of the 1980s and 1990s, Rabinowitz's investigative study brings to life many alarming examples of prosecutorial terrors. By turns a shocking exposé, a much-needed postmortem, and a required-reading assignment for prosecutors and judges alike, No Crueler Tyrannies is ultimately an inspiring book about the courage of ordinary citizens who believe in the American judicial system enough to fight for due process.
The Mind That Is Catholic: Philosophical & Political Essays by Fr. James V. Schall. The author is a treasure of the Catholic intellectual tradition. A prolific author and essayist, Schall readily connects with his readers on sundry topics from war to friendship, philosophy, politics, and to ordinary everyday living. In his newest work, The Mind That Is Catholic, he presents a retrospective collection of his academic and literary essays written in the past fifty years. In each essay, he exemplifies the Catholic mind at its best - seeing the whole, leaving nothing out.
Knowledge and Power: The Information Theory of Capitalism and How it is Revolutionizing our World by George Gilder. Gilder breaks away from the supply-side model of economics to present a new economic paradigm: the epic conflict between the knowledge of entrepreneurs on one side, and the blunt power of government on the other. One of the twentieth century’s defining economic minds has returned with a new philosophy to carry us into the twenty-first. Knowledge and Power is a must-read for fiscal conservatives, business owners, CEOs, investors, and anyone interested in propelling America’s economy to future success.
The Evidential Power of Beauty: Science and Theology Meet by Fr. Thomas Dubay, S.M. "This is as complete a theology of beauty in one simple volume as I know, uniting Christian theology, modern science, and daily experience—a sort of von Balthasar for the masses. It vastly expands our understanding beyond 'aesthetics', and shows us how nearly right Keats was in saying 'Beauty is truth, truth is beauty.'" Peter Kreeft, Professor of Philosophy at Boston College and The King's College.
Reasonable Pleasures: The Strange Coherences of Catholicism by Fr. James Schall SJ. "A timely treatise when the sources of our being, and indeed of our culture, are challenged on a daily basis. Schall is one of the foremost Catholic intellectuals of our day." Jude Dougherty, Dean Emeritus, Philosophy Department, Catholic University of America.
America Alone: The End of the World as We Know It by Mark Steyn. Mark Steyn predicted collapse for the rest of the Western World. Now, he adds, America has caught up with Europe on the great rush to self-destruction. It’s not just our looming financial collapse; it’s not just a culture that seems on a fast track to perdition, full of hapless, indulgent, childish people who think government has the answer for every problem; it’s not just America’s potential eclipse as a world power because of the drunken sailor policymaking in Washington— No, it’s all this and more that spells one word for America: Armageddon.
1492 And All That by Robert Royal. Readers will learn a great deal, and an honest appraisal of the Catholic Church's true history, not the gunk that passes for such as found in too many college and university courses. Royal argues that the values and beliefs actually held by America's original cultures are being misrepresented. They are merely, he contends, remoldings of ancient Native beliefs in order to fit a modern agenda. His contentions are supported with detailed examples of pre-Columbian Native customs and behaviors.
American Betrayal by Diana West, lights up the massive, Moscow-directed penetration of America’s most hallowed halls of power, revealing not just the familiar struggle between Communism and the Free World, but the hidden war between those wishing to conceal the truth and those trying to expose the increasingly official web of lies. American Betrayal is America’s lost history.
My Peace I Give You by Dawn Eden. The author of the bestselling The Thrill of the Chaste, shows how the lives of the saints have given her hope and aided her journey of spiritual healing after childhood sexual abuse. One in four American women and one in six American men report having been sexually abused during childhood and My Peace I Give You: Healing Sexual Wounds with the Help of the Saints provides a much-needed resource for spiritual healing from the isolating effects of these wounds. This new book has the makings of a classic. A true must read.
Civilization. The West and the Rest by Niall Ferguson. The author of the highly readable The Ascent of Money is magnificent at marshaling a wide range of knowledge to support his opinions. This book is an incisive analysis of the past, a reassessment of the historical developments of the last 500 years that should inform us as we move into the future.
Heaven In Our Hands by Benedict Groeschel. Father Benedict Groeschel believes that we've lost touch with how revolutionary the Beatitudes really are! The plain but astounding truth is that the Beatitudes reveal to us the very heart of God.
The Devil's Delusion by David Berlinski. Berlinski delivers a biting defense of religious thought, daring to ask and answer some rather embarrassing questions.
Mexifornia : A State of a Becoming by Victor Davis Hanson. A revealing look at the changing face of California paints a clear but rather glum picture at the Golden State's future prospects.
Intellectual Morons by Daniel Flynn. Why do smart people fall for stupid ideas? "Intellectual Morons," are smart people who make themselves stupid by letting "ideology do their thinking." Flynn lambastes a series of prominent leftist "gurus" and the ideological movements they inspired.
Demonic by Ann Coulter. How Liberals are endangering America. Sweeping in its scope and relentless in its argument, this book explains the peculiarities of liberals as standard groupthink behavior. To understand mobs is to understand liberals.
How The Catholic Church Built Western Civilization by Thomas E. Woods Jr. For readers looking to defend Western Civilization and their faith.
Dismantling America and Other Controversial Essays by Thomas Sowell. A straightforward and honest discussion of the origins of our current crisis.
There Is No Alternative: Why Margaret Thatcher Matters by Claire Berlinsky. A biographical account of the premiership of Margaret Thatcher.
The Enemy at Home: The Cultural Left and Its Responsibility for 9/11 by Dinesh D'Souza. The left is waging an aggressive global campaign to undermine the traditional patriarchal family, provoking a violent reaction from Muslims who believe their way of life is under assault. Further, the cultural left has encouraged radical factions to attack the United States in the belief that they can do so with relative impunity.

Latest Articles

Popular Articles

Published Elsewhere

About the Author

Carlos Caso-Rosendi Real progress consists in the movement of mankind toward the understanding of norms, and toward conformity to norms. Real decadence consists in the movement of mankind away from the understanding of norms, and away from obedience to norms. Russell Kirk, Enemies of the Permanent Things, 1969